FAQ

Frequently Asked Questions

Last updated: June 28, 2023


Why is nobody chatting? Is anyone reading this?

Most likely, yes. Economics discord has users within the community that come from all parts of the world from Mongolia to Kenya, Norway and Peru to name a few. Because of the difference in schedules there is not any particular hour that is the most active. Users send hundreds of messages in our server community every day. If you wait a little, someone will most likely engage in the chat.


I need help with my economics/statistics/applied math homework, can I ask for help?

Yes, absolutely. Providing help for these topics is one of our main missions or goals in the server. Our rules require that you have at least made an attempt to complete the work, in other words, we are not going to do the work for you.


I have a question about economics or economies. Can I ask it?

Yes! Please ask your general questions about economics either in the general chat, in #econ_help or in a topical channel.
You do not need to seek permission to ask questions and it is easier for us to answer if you just post your question directly.


I have a question about politics or political ideologies. Can I ask it?

No!


There are so many channels! Where should I post my questions?

Try to use the channel which seems most appropriate, though as a default the #econ_help channel is always good to ask questions. Broader questions or questions which might interest the larger community can be asked in #general_chat.


A friend or I believe they were wrongfully banned from the server, is there any capacity to reinstate a user in this case?

Yes. There is a process for reinstatement of users who were previously banned from the server.
However this process is very rarely used and most cases are documented rules violations with little or no need to revisit the circumstances of the removal.


Can I discuss significant current events?

Yes with some caveats. In order to streamline the operation of the server, minimize the need for moderation and to maintain a specific focus of the server we ask that you discuss current events only insofar as it relates to the current or historical economic context.


Why do you hate Austrian and heterodox economics?

Many of us are aware of the ideas of Austrian economics. In direct contrast with Austrian economics views, we choose to focus our time on methods and theories that are supported by extensive data collection and rigorous econometric analysis.
There are many other outlets on the internet for discussing Austrian economics that would be more suitable than our server.
In terms of policy, to the best of our knowledge the only valid analysis of policies is quantitative analysis that utilizes advanced econometrics techniques.


I want to know how to get accepted to graduate school in economics. How do I do that?

In economics there are primarily two types of graduate programs, a master's in economics and a doctor of philosophy (PhD) in economics. In broad terms, individuals who get a PhD often plan to take jobs as professors at universities or doing advanced research in non-profit organizations. Master's programs in economics prepare most students to be professional economists and equip them with the basic tools of economics and econometrics that are necessary to be a functioning professional economist. To get accepted to most graduate programs you must complete the graduate entrance examination known as the GRE.


I want to know how to get accepted to graduate school in economics, can I ask you about my background?

In general, questions about specific programs or a specific individual's background are not permitted. One reason is because this information is not particularly useful to other users. First-hand accounts of user's experiences are allowed.


I have a question about advanced econometric methods. Can you answer it?

We will do our best. Please recognize that even econometrics as a sub-discipline is very broad and involves a wide range of techniques. It is very rare for any single individual to be trained and skilled in all of those areas in both the theoretical and applied sense. The vast majority of questions about econometrics we receive relate to applied econometric analysis.


I study or work in finance but I don't know much about economics. How do economics and finance relate?

Finance is strongly related to or even part of economics. Some aspects of the analysis of financial markets that relate to economics and are particularly important are: central banks, banking and financial regulation and foreign exchange/sovereign debt. Often, financial analysts use time series analysis, which is a type of statistical (econometric) modeling used for forecasting.
Quantitative traders may use time series techniques or more advanced econometric models. Financial analysis is most closely related to macroeconomic analysis, though microeconometric techniques and microeconomic models are also used to model asset prices in what is known as the "microeconomics of finance."
Econometrics, in particular, is a useful tool for individuals looking to enter into quantitative analysis or algorithmic trading. According to the course description in one particularly well-known program:
"Quantitative methods have become fundamental tools in the analysis and planning of financial operations... . .. In this course, models for hedging, asset a/location, and multi-period portfolio planning are developed, implemented, and tested. In addition, pricing models for options, bonds, mortgage-backed securities, and other derivatives are studied. The models typically require the tools of statistics, optimization, and/or simulation, and they are implemented in spreadsheets or a high-level modeling environment, MATLAB.
This course is quantitative and will require extensive computer use. The course is intended for students who have strong interest in finance. The objective is to provide students the necessary practical tools they will require should they choose to join the financial services industry, particularly in roles such as: derivatives, quantitative trading, portfolio management, structuring, financial engineering, risk management, etc."
https://fnce.wharton.upenn.edu/quantitative-finance-major/